Worst Company in America 2012 - Round One: Comcast vs Time Warner, Dish vs DirecTV - DTV USA Forum
Subscribe via RSS Feed

  • Worst Company in America 2012 - Round One: Comcast vs Time Warner, Dish vs DirecTV

    Ah, spring is in the air! And with it comes annual traditions, like Easter and March Madness. No, I'm not talking about the basketball March Madness. I'm talking about "March Madness", Consumerist style!

    Every year, Consumerist.com conducts it's annual "Worst Company In America" tournament, better known to Consumeristas as "The WCIA". Readers nominate companies they deem worthy of this fabulous prize, then Consumerist staff selects the most nominated companies and set them up in "Brackets", just like that other March Madness thingie you may have heard about. Readers then vote for their least favorite companies in match-ups like this one: Comcast vs Time Warner. The winner (Loser?) proceeds to the next round to face another equally (un?)worthy corporate devil. The loser (winner?) gets bragging rights to say, "Well, at least we aren't as evil as company X!" And so it goes, until the last company left standing is declared the winner (loser?) and is awarded the coveted "Golden Poo":


    The Golden Poo

    I'm pretty sure all of us here have had, um, "experiences" with these Pay TV providers. I'm also pretty sure that whatever company brings you your internet and/or pay TV, yours is the worst. At least as far as you're concerned.

    So today, good readers of DTV USA Forums, take a stand against corporate greed and incompetence. Get out there and VOTE in round one of THE WORST COMPANY IN AMERICA!

    See all current competitors- http://consumerist.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-search.cgi?blog_id=1&tag=wcia 2012&limit=20

    Vote here for Comcast vs Time Warner- http://consumerist.com/2012/03/worst-company-in-america-round-one-comcast-vs-time-warner-cable.html

    Vote here for DirecTV vs Dish- http://consumerist.com/2012/03/worst...network-1.html

    This year's field is difficult, with so many worthy competitors. This year's odds-on favorite is believed by many to be the evil Bank of America, who were denied a well deserved Golden Poo last year when BP's little accident in the Gulf of Mexico crushed the hopes of thousands who had been trampled by BofA and their forclosures-and-fees shenanigans.

    Comcast has always been a perennial favorite, and a former Champion.

    Kiplinger's picked Consumerist.com as "Best Consumer Blog" for their annual "Best List" featured in the December 2010 issue, Best of Everything 2010: Best Personal-Finance Resources Flip to the top of page 80 and you'll see they say we are the "always useful, frequently fun and deliciously snarky place to get the latest on a wide array of consumer issues."
    Comments 9 Comments
    1. dkreichen1968's Avatar
      dkreichen1968 -
      Comcast has a distinct advantage in this round of the competition given that they have 10 million more customers than TWC. So, I don't know if it's going to be a fair fight. Since these MSO aren't head to head competitors I don't know if it can be fair. There are millions of people who have Comcast who have never had the chance to have TWC and the other way around. Now, the Dish/DirecTV fight is fairer, and my guess (having had neither but having friends who have had both) that Dish will win hands down, but will be taken out by a legacy cable company in the WCIA multichannel finals.
    1. Thomas G's Avatar
      Thomas G -
      I have DirecTV and the service itself isn't that bad. I just hate talking to tech support. Between the hold times and uneducated employees, I'd rather just try to fix my problems myself. Which is what they probably want anyway.

      Still, it's not bad enough for me to say that they are the worst company in America. Most of the banks are deserving of brown poo, not golden poo.
    1. MrPogi's Avatar
      MrPogi -
      Thomas G: I'm sure that the banks in the WCIA banks charge you a fee to lend you poo of any kind. Also, bad customer service is generally what gets companies nominated for WCIA. Your product / service may be great, but bad policies and poor service are what upset a lot of people about these companies.
    1. TVTom51's Avatar
      TVTom51 -
      what i hate is overseas tech support. i can't understand a damn thing any of the tech support people say at XM Radio and most of the time they get my account changes wrong when I call in. I'd vote for XM radio if they were up there on the list to vote for as worst company.
    1. MrPogi's Avatar
      MrPogi -
      UPDATE:

      SCHEDULE OF WORST COMPANY IN AMERICA 2012 BOUTS

      SWEET 16
      MARCH 21:
      * Noon ET: Best Buy vs. EA
      * 2:00 p.m. ET: Facebook vs. USPS

      MARCH 22:
      * 9:30 a.m. ET: Comcast vs. DirecTV
      * Noon ET: Bank of America vs. Citi
      * 2:00 p.m. ET: Ticketmaster vs. Spirit Airlines
      MARCH 23:
      * 9:30 a.m. ET: PayPal vs. Charter
      * Noon ET: AT&T vs. Walmart
      * 2:00 p.m. ET: Walmart vs. GameStop
    1. dkreichen1968's Avatar
      dkreichen1968 -
      Quote Originally Posted by MrPogi View Post
      UPDATE:

      SCHEDULE OF WORST COMPANY IN AMERICA 2012 BOUTS

      SWEET 16
      MARCH 21:
      * Noon ET: Best Buy vs. EA
      * 2:00 p.m. ET: Facebook vs. USPS

      MARCH 22:
      * 9:30 a.m. ET: Comcast vs. DirecTV
      * Noon ET: Bank of America vs. Citi
      * 2:00 p.m. ET: Ticketmaster vs. Spirit Airlines
      MARCH 23:
      * 9:30 a.m. ET: PayPal vs. Charter
      * Noon ET: AT&T vs. Walmart
      * 2:00 p.m. ET: Walmart vs. GameStop
      I see in the multichannel video area that the companies with the most customers "won." To make the fights fairer, they should weight the results. It's strange that DirecTV beat Dish while on the other hand DirecTV has been consistently adding customers even when Dish was losing customers.
    1. MrPogi's Avatar
      MrPogi -
      Perhaps the correct name for the contest should be "most hated"?

      Because that's what it's really counting: How many people hate company X.
    1. CaptSteve's Avatar
      CaptSteve -
      You need to add Mediacomm to the final four. By far the worst cable company, if not the worst company I've ever dealt with. I built a $80M EDI company in seven years and it didn't happen treating people the way Mediacomm treats it's customers!
    1. dkreichen1968's Avatar
      dkreichen1968 -
      Quote Originally Posted by CaptSteve View Post
      You need to add Mediacomm to the final four. By far the worst cable company, if not the worst company I've ever dealt with. I built a $80M EDI company in seven years and it didn't happen treating people the way Mediacomm treats it's customers!
      Well Mediacom only has 1.1 million customers, while Comcast has 22 million customers. Both are cable companies, and people hate cable companies (though not enough to figure out they are obsolete). Comcast can actually be better and still get a lot more votes.
    Comments Leave Comment (Guest comments are moderated)

    Click here to log in

    Complete this sentence: "How ___ you today?" (Hint 3 letter word) (Answer this question correctly, it is used to stop spammers)

Back to top