The purpose of the change over is to free up the spectrum currently used for channels 52 through 69. The change to
DTV is being made part of this just because they can. It's not at all essential for analog TV to be dropped in order to allow
DTV and
DTV is not needed to free up the bandwidth. You can pickup
DTV signals right now while still receiving analog TV as well.
I am sure that people will say it's too expensive to maintain both analog and digital transmitters, but I don't buy that. That's what the broadcasters are doing right now!!!
There is a "cliff" effect with digital TV where the picture quality goes from great with a strong signal to great with slightly lower signal to very bad to none at all with a moderate strength signal. I'll put it this way, none of the stations that I watch using analog TV will be receivable once they switch to digital. If the analog picture has noticeable snow, not objectionable, just noticeable, the digital signal is likely to not be receivable. I don't know what level of multipath will prevent receiption, but that can also be a problem.
So if you live in a city that has TV stations, you will likely receive a
DTV signal ok. But if you live further out from the city or are behind hills so that you get a weaker signal, you are likely to not be able to receive a digital TV signal over the air.
Rick