TV Fool
VHF
NBC KPLC-DT RF07 (7.1) 57.9NM 136 deg
UHF
CBS KALB-TV RF35 (5.2) 33.0NM 56 deg
ABC KATC-DT RF28 (3.1) 34.3NM 109 deg
FOX KVHP-DT RF30 (29.1) 45.9MN 223 deg
What doesn't make sense but I believe because no map is perfect that
KVHP would be the weakest station.
I see one way to do it with two antennas. You may end up with a mulitpath problem or maybe not.
You would buy small VHF/UHF array and point it somewhere between KPLC and KATC in Lafayette. Then are 27 degrees apart, within the beam of say a HBU22.
Then take a Antennacraft U-4000 and don't unfold the reflector elements.
Take a Winegard
CC 7870 2-Way Antenna Joiner Coupler and put the output of the HBU22 into the side that is power passive.
Then take the output of the U-4000 into a Winegard AP 4700 Chromstar 2000 Series UHF Pre Amplifier, then the output of the preamp into the active side of the
CC 7870.
Then the output of the 7870 to the TV.
The idea behind not unfolding the reflector elements makes it pick up in two directions. Off the front and back. Then tend to still favor the front, so point the front at KVHP and it should pick up KALB off the back.
This is even deep in the experimental category. I know several people that live with stations in all directions and they have tried a lot of combination to get things to work.
All in all you are begging for a rotor but I understand the Tivo problem with a rotor. It's too bad Tivo doesn't make a model that has outputs to drive a remote control A/B switch, so it could switch between antennas as it recorded one channel or another. It would still not solve recording 2 channels at once.
Let me know if my idea makes sense.
The one thing I am not sure with saying KVHP is weak if you would need an 8 bay with the reflector not unfolded or removed. But with signals in the 30 range on NB (
db), with an amp it should work. The Winegard 7870 combiner is made to run an amp through one side and not the other.
Then I hope that KATC is strong enough not to need an amp.
=====
I guess with you saying some stations are hard to get, you are using some kind of antenna now? If so what is it and where is it? And are you running an amp now?