Welcome to the forum Matt, hope you don't mind I moved your thread to the reception area.
We're probably going to need your
www.tvfool.com results before we can give you a few ideas on how to help with your reception.
TVFool will help us figure out how far you are from broadcast towers and let you know which channels you should be able to receive. Once you've input your address and approximate antenna height (for an indoor antenna, I'd put 5' or less), copy and paste the results page here along with which channels you're looking to receive.